This site is only being updated in part now. Existing full posts will still remain, but for new blogs and more information on me, please see my new website HERE

Monday 23 December 2013

When Victorian railways conspired against Christmas

One of the features of the late Victorian British railway industry was competition, with railways in all parts of the nation trying to out-perform each other in order to win the patronage of passengers. From the 1880s the Great Western and London & South Western Railways accelerated their services as well as increased the luxury in which passengers were conveyed, to secure the business to West Country locations such as Exeter and Plymouth.[1] Competition between companies also existed on the routes between Nottingham and Leeds, Liverpool and Hull, and Edinburgh and Glasgow, as well as between other major cities.[2]

Some historians have argued that these struggles between railways were a major factor in their declining profitability after 1870, as faster trains and more luxurious carriages cost more to build and operate. Cain, for example, stated his belief that ‘service competition alone would have been sufficient to promote levels of capital spending and methods of operation that continuously eroded profitability.’[3] Personally, I have always doubted the extent to which competitive trains services actually eroded companies’ profitability. I argued in my thesis, on the management of the London & South Western Railway after 1870, that service competition was on the margins of the railway’s activities. It and the GWR ran hundreds of services each day and only four or five express services to the West Country were truly ‘competitive.’[4]

One of the fiercest competitions between railway companies were the famed ‘Races to the North’ in 1888 and 1895. Two groups of companies that had control of the east and west coast main lines competed for the fastest trains between London and Scotland. On the east coast route the competitors were the Great Northern (London to York), North Eastern (York to Edinburgh) and North British Railways (Edinburgh to Aberdeen); while on the west coast route the contestants were the London and North Western (London to Carlisle) and Caledonian Railways (Carlisle to Edinburgh and Aberdeen). The race of 1895, which received the same attention in the press as the derby at Cheltenham, captured the public’s imagination, culminating in a west coast train on the night of 22 and 23 August making the journey between London and Aberdeen in 8 hours 42 minutes. This was eight minutes quicker than an east coast train the night before.[5]

Because of events like this, the press liked to paint these railway races as battles between warring powers. But how serious was the animosity between the companies? Did the east and west coast railways really treat their competitors as enemies? Or were the ‘races’ just an exuberant, but good-natured, expression of a rivalry between them? Perhaps an event that occurred before Christmas 1882 suggests an answer to these questions.

In early December 1882 a very thick letter arrived at King’s Cross headquarters of the Great Northern Railway. Before a list of 214 names was a letter addressed to those in authority within company:

Gentlemen
   We the undersigned draw your attention to the fact that there are in London many Scotchmen who desire to avail themselves of the opportunity of visiting their friends in Scotland during the short vacation at Christmas but are deterred from doing so by the heavy railway fares.
We would therefore petition to you to give this subject your full consideration and endeavour to make some arrangement, whereby the result aimed at by your petitioners may be gained namely: a reasonable reduction in fares between London and Scotland equal to, if not quarter than that granted during the summer months.
   We are certain that should you see your way to meet us in this matter, it would not only confer a great boon, but from the large numbers availing themselves of the opportunity, prove equally to your advantage.
   We are yours respectfully… [6]


But this petition was not the only one to be sent, and a duplicate also landed on the desk of George Findlay, the London and North Western Railway’s General Manager. I suspect Findlay’s natural response was to reject the request. But he was an astute railway manager, and possibly because he wished to maintain good relations with his east coast rivals, he contacted to his opposite number within the GNR, Henry Oakley. ‘As I presume a similar application has been addressed to you’, wrote Findlay ‘I shall be glad to know if you will be prepared to join us in declining to accede to the request.’[7] Oakley’s response is not contained within the file, but the two companies decided to reject the petition. Findlay also communicated with the Midland Railway, who likewise operated a route between London and Scotland, and while they had not received a petition, they too were to going to keep fares at established levels. [8]

In 1882 three railway companies, all of which were theoretically competing with each other for traffic between London and Scotland, collectively agreed to deny travellers making this journey reduce-rate fares over the Christmas period. Of course, this case does not indicate the nature of the GNR and LNWR’s relationship five or ten years later when they were racing. Nevertheless, it may suggest that despite superficially appearing to be competing railways, as a matter of fact their relationship was actually quite close and they worked together when it was mutually beneficial for them to do so. ‘Market forces’, in this case at least, did not really work. One thing is for certain, the Great Northern, London & North Western and Midland Railways spoiled Christmas for a lot of London-based Scotsmen and their families in 1882.

--

[1] Jack Simmons, ‘South Western v. Great Western: railway competition in Devon and Cornwall’, The Journal of Transport History, 4 (1959), 27-34
[2] Jack Simmons, The Victorian Railway, (London, 1991), p.83; Jack Simmons, The Railway in England and Wales, 1830-1914, (Leicester, 1978), p.84-85
[3] P.J. Cain, ‘Railways 1870-1914: the maturity of the private system’, in, Michael J. Freeman and Derek H. Aldcroft, Transport in Victorian Britain, (Manchester, 1988), pp.115
[4] David Turner, ‘Managing the “Royal Road”: The London & South Western Railway 1870-1911’, (Unpublished PhD Thesis. University of York, 2013)
[5] Oswald S. Nock, The Railway Race to the North, (London, 1958), p.120-121
[6] The National Archives [TNA], RAIL 236/721/9, From London `Scotchmen' asking for reduction in fares to Scotland during Christmas vacation, Letter from organisation committee to Great Northern Railway, 4 December 1882
[7] TNA, RAIL 236/721/9, From London `Scotchmen' asking for reduction in fares to Scotland during Christmas vacation, Letter from George Findlay to Henry Oakley, 11 December 1882
[8] TNA, RAIL 236/721/9, From London `Scotchmen' asking for reduction in fares to Scotland during Christmas vacation, Letter from George Findlay to Henry Oakley, 13 December 1882

25 comments:

  1. The word, I think is: "Cartel"
    In the same way, even though train speeds were increasing (as well as weights) the ridiculous 8.5 hour limitation on the London-Edinburgh time was kept until IIRC 1932.

    ReplyDelete
  2. and no trains shall run on the Lord's Day: www.flickr.com/photos/tarkaman/4395329181

    ReplyDelete
  3. This article is quite interesting and I am looking forward to reading more of your posts. Thanks for sharing this article with us.
    Essay Writing Help,
    Essay Writer

    ReplyDelete
  4. Looking for the Mobile App Development Companies in Delhi, Find the No.1 Directory Top Web India and Explore the Best IT companies in India.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I recommend to write such more post like this as it will encourage others.I also recommend visiting mobile app development company

    ReplyDelete
  6. If you are looking for the Finance Accounting Assignments help then in this case you can opt for our Finance Accounting Assignments help.we provide the best Accounting and Finance Assignment.We also provide Financial Reporting Assignment Help for students across the globe. for more information contact us +16692714848.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Excellent information. Thank you for sharing this insightful blog.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Office.com/setup: Avail of premium apps like PowerPoint, Word, Excel on your device by downloading, installing, and activating at Office.com/setup.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Howdy, I’m Adam. I’m a web developer living in 1013 Drummond Street, Newark, New Jersey,07102. I am a fan of technology, gaming, and design. I’m also interested in web development and programming.
    Webroot login
    Office.com/setup

    ReplyDelete
  10. Nice post!! Real-time conferencing is very helpful to conduct better app ideas to build successful software. Contact video streaming app development company to know more.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Hey, would you mind if I share your blog on my social media channels? There are a lot of folks that I think would enjoy reading your content. Please let me know. Thank you.
    app development
    app development companies india

    ReplyDelete
  12. Awesome blog. I enjoyed reading your articles. this is often truly an excellent read on behalf of me . I even have bookmarked it and that i am looking forward to reading new articles. continue the great work!

    ReplyDelete
  13. Our commerce assignment help specialists are knowledgeable with English jargon and are capable in writing a very much organized assignment with no linguistic blunders, right utilization of accentuation and noteworthy perception. The writers giving managerial economics assignment help are very much aware and aware of adhering to the rules and arranging guidelines given by the college and workforce. economics assignment help

    ReplyDelete
  14. Very Well Explained your Blog is just amazing and provides profound knowledge. I would also like to induce your attention to mobile app development company .

    ReplyDelete
  15. Best Self Defense Training in Dehradun VR Combatives Academy is available to teach you the best training for self-protection through defending techniques.Self Defense Classes near me for Martial Arts is defending yourself from an opponent’s attack in any situation.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Our experts give you Self Defense training by teaching the different methods using Strike techniques, Kick techniques, Escaping techniques, prevention tips and more. Also, Self Defense through martial art will make you learn mixed martial arts, including Judo, Jeet Kune Do, Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu, boxing and more. Looking for Best Self Defense Training in Dehradun near you in Dehradun? VR Combatives Academy is the Best Self Defense Classes in Dehradun

    ReplyDelete
  17. Self Defense training near me for Martial Arts is defending yourself from an opponent’s attack in any situation. Most of our students joined our Academy to learn Self Defense Classes in dehradun


    ReplyDelete
  18. you should share your necessities so your writer works by remembering them. Plainly notice the kind of scholastic paper you need us to compose, regardless of whether it is an assignment, exposition, theory, or an article. Remember to determine the theme, word count, citation style, deadline date, etc. my assignment help

    ReplyDelete
  19. Over the years, people have continued to give flowers. The mimosa flower carries this special meaning, but other flowers are also used to convey the same message. The tulip is one of these flowers.
    Own language
    Women's Day Flowers

    ReplyDelete
  20. You made some good points there. I searched for the subject matter and found most individuals will go along with your blog.
    스포츠토토탑

    ReplyDelete
  21. Excellent post. i need to thanks for this informative article. i actually appreciate sharing this nice post. sustain your work.
    토토

    ReplyDelete
  22. Great information, this information is necessary and essential for everyone. I am heartily thankful to you for providing this kind of great information. Thank you once again for sharing it. New Holland Tractor

    ReplyDelete
  23. The new report by Expert Market Research titled, ‘Global Interior Design Services Market Report and Forecast 2022-2027’, gives an in-depth analysis of the global Interior Design Services Market, assessing the market based on its segments like end-uses, and major regions. The report tracks the latest trends in the industry and studies their impact on the overall market. Interior design services are gaining traction owing to the increasing investments by the residents to enhance the design of small rooms, kitchen, and bedrooms for greater comfort. Over the forecast period, the increasing residential construction owing to the rapid urbanisation and increasing standards of living is anticipated to propel the demand for interior design services in the forecast period. The major players in the market are AECOM, Gensler. M. Arthur Gensler Jr. & Associates Inc., Jacobs Engineering Group Inc., Perkins & Will International Group of Companies, and Stantec Inc., among others. Expert Market Research have 500+ analyst team that provide our clients A+ services. We are providing expansive industry data and help them in formulating market and business strategies. For more information about our services. You can visit our website.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Nice Blog, this information is excellent and very important for everyone. Thanks
    Birla Tractor Tyre

    ReplyDelete
  25. nice and interesting piece of information you have shared. you can also check<a href="https://infoguidenigeria.com/crk-jamb-past-question/"

    ReplyDelete

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...